Two kinds of Israeli parents are worried about the IDF. One is waiting for a son to come home from reserve duty. The other is afraid of what the military would make of a son who’s never set foot in it. Between them runs an argument as old as the state, and a week and a half before the election, everyone is debating it.
Israel drafts most Jewish 18-year-olds, sons and daughters alike. The Haredim (ultra-Orthodox) are the great exception. They’re more than 14% of the Israeli population today and on course to be 25% by mid-century.
Since the state’s earliest years, a Haredi man studying full time in yeshiva could put off his service year after year, until he aged out of it for good. In 1949, Ben-Gurion granted that option to about 400 students. Today, about 80,000 Haredi men of draft age are eligible to serve, and last year only about 4,000 showed up.
For decades, governments tried to write the arrangement into law, and for decades they failed. The last legal arrangement lapsed in June 2023. A year later, the Supreme Court ruled that without a law, the state had no grounds to keep exempting yeshiva students. It had to start drafting them.
What makes it urgent now is October 7, and the idea that died that morning. When Ehud Barak became chief of staff in 1991, he gave the IDF a motto: “small and smart”. Intelligence, air power and technology would keep our enemies from ever daring a real war. We believed we had deterrence. For three decades we built our military around this concept, or as Israelis call it, “the conceptzia”.
On October 7 the conceptzia collapsed. Three years of war on several fronts have followed, and the IDF says it’s about 12,000 soldiers short, about 7,000 of them in combat units.
The draft has already split the coalition. In July 2025, the Haredi United Torah Judaism party walked out of the government over the exemption law that never passed, and Shas pulled its ministers out as well. The court has since ordered the state to enforce the draft, and struck down a law that would have frozen the arrests.
Israelis view the refusal to carry the burden as deeply unfair. The same families send their children to Gaza and Lebanon, then send them back again and again. Some never return. A law enforced on one neighbor and not the next is no longer a law, and everyone who serves feels it.
To the Haredim, a young man studying Talmud protects Israel as surely as a soldier on the border. Torah has kept the Jewish people alive for two thousand years without a state or a military, and they see no reason to believe it stopped in 1948.
The military, as they see it, is the gravest threat to their way of life. The IDF was built to take 18-year-olds from every corner of the country and turn them into Israelis. It’s a melting pot. And that’s precisely what Haredi parents fear. A boy who goes in leaves behind his rabbi, his study partner, and a day built around learning. He serves alongside women. He takes orders from commanders instead of rabbis. His parents worry he’ll come home a different man, and raise different children. He may leave the fold completely.
The political parties’ answers to this problem run the length of the spectrum. The Haredi parties want a full exemption with no sanctions. The coalition worked on a bill to draft Haredim slowly, with targets that start small and rise over the years, but Netanyahu put it off until after the election. The opposition wants universal service, with a narrow exception for top scholars at most, backed by real enforcement and economic sanctions for anyone who doesn’t serve.
For most of Israel’s history, Israelis who served resented the Haredi exemption, but it was rarely top of mind. We mostly grumbled and moved on. October 7 changed that. Israel needs a military that’s big and smart now, and the Haredim are the largest group of young Jewish men who don’t serve. We need them. The grumble has become a demand, and the country is saying enough is enough.
The way I see it, there are two Israels in this country: Order 8 Israel, and Order 12 Israel. Order 8 is the IDF’s emergency call-up notice for reservists. Order 12 is the final summons sent to draft dodgers before issuing an arrest warrant.
Order 8 Israel votes for every party, and is the overwhelming majority. The Likud voter in Ashdod, the Yesh Atid voter in Ra’anana, the settler in Ofra and the kibbutznik on the border all get the same order. They serve in the same units and stand at the same funerals. They argue bitterly about judges, about the Palestinians, about who should lead this country. But on the question that has cost them the most these past three years, they have far more in common with each other than any of them has with the other Israel. Yet our politics don’t reflect it, and the smaller Israel holds the larger one hostage.
This election gives us a rare chance to undo a mistake made in the state’s first years, one that has let the smaller Israel grow and flourish on the back of the larger. Some say the change has to come slowly and gently. But we’ve had nearly 80 years of slow and gentle, and it has left us with 80,000 able-bodied men who don’t serve.
We don’t have another 80 years to wait. The stakes are higher than ever. This is our most urgent national security priority. Order 12 Israel must serve this country the way its Order 8 brothers and sisters do. They must share the burden equally.
Three years ago, Order 8 Israel dropped everything the moment the order came. In eleven days, it’s called up once more, this time to a ballot box. Nobody in this country knows better how to answer the call.
Shabbat shalom,
Josh Ben-David
Founder, Daily Lion
Quick update
I’ve decided to abandon the AI podcasts and instead do my own, I just haven’t figured out the right format yet. I’m working on it and will hopefully be able to share my first episode next week. We’ll see how it goes :)
State of the art
Thanks for reading! If you enjoyed this, feel free to support our work by sharing it with your friends.
Daily Lion is a podcast about Israel and the Jewish people that takes the most important stories of the moment, and lays them out how the left, right, and center see them. Then we add our own perspective and let you decide. Learn more about us here: www.dailylionmedia.com



